Talking to people about this keeps making me angry. There just aren't a lot of people who seem able to talk sense about the situation. There's an American arrogance which gets more and more painful to listen to each time I hear it, and an inability to think seriously about the consequences of our actions which will lead to our downfall.
People keep jumping to conclusions about who did this, first of all. We don't know anything yet. We make all these assumptions so quickly, because we feel that we need to take action quickly, and I'm worried that for a lot of people it doesn't matter whether we're attacking the right people or not, as long as someone pays for this. As long as we're looking for the terrorists, we might as well just attack whatever country we think they're in, and do we really think that we're only going to punish the people responsible? They killed our civilians, we'll kill their civilians. But because ours died first does that make theirs any less innocent?
Bush's speech last night made me sick for a lot of reasons. There was this whole "attack on our way of life" and "beacon of light" thing. We were attacked because we are a beacon of light and hope and freedom for the world? I know that the situation somehow requires him to say something like that, but who are we kidding? He makes it seem like the terrorists have something against hope and freedom. Which brings me to my next point: his constant use of the word evil. Evil is something beyond bad or wrong, and it seems to me more like a fairy tale concept than one that appears regularly in real life. Stenny made a pretty good distinction here and here about the evil thing, so I won't rehash it too much. At any rate, defining someone as evil places a black hat on his/her head, suggesting that they are motivated only by a desire to do wrong. Are we so narrow-minded as to think that our point of view is the only right one? Whoever did this did not say "Ooooh, a beacon of light and freedom and hope. I hate light and freedom and hope, so I think I'll attack it." Please. It's not as if everything this country has ever done has been in the name of freedom and hope. On the contrary, ask anyone in the Middle East what they think of us, and you're bound to get an unfavorable response, because what we represent to them is not light and freedom and hope but death and oppression and the destruction of their way of life. If someone from that area is responsible for this, I can only say: they were not the first to kill civilians.
This whole "cowardly" thing is bothering me too. If I had any drawing skills, I could probably make a decent political cartoon about that one. We have probably the strongest army and national defense in the world. Could a small terrorist group, probably coming from a small country which we probably at one point laid ruin, possibly be expected to come face to face with us in a direct fight? Not if they wanted to actually accomplish something. They just used the best means available to them.
I don't know what is going to happen next, but I just don't think it is going to end well. I've accepted that we have to respond to this somehow, but I feel sure that the government is going to act rashly. So many people in the country are so angry, and so filled with this lust for revenge, that it's just politically expedient to act quickly. The American people aren't going to be too happy with slow and deliberate, and there's reelections to think about. And for some reason innocent people in other countries are worth less than reelection prospects. Oh yes, that's right, it's because they're evil. I remember now. I know I'm being cynical about this, but I can't help it. Sometimes I feel like I'm rooting for the wrong side, but just because I love this country doesn't mean that I agree with every decision we've ever made. People may say that I would feel differently if I actually knew anyone who had been killed, but I'm not so sure. My reaction to this has been more like a reaction to a natural disaster, a hurricane or tornado or flood, because if we treat other countries the way we have been for so many years, what can we expect?
spake the Amanda Hope at 11:15 AM (linkme)